| Bethel Conservative Church |
25402 CR 50 |
| Bible Way Apostolic Church |
26148 US 6 E |
| Calvary Baptist Church |
201 E. Market Street |
| First Mennonite Church |
900 W. Market Street |
| Grace Point Church |
1155 N. Main Street |
| Hepton Union Church |
9266 W. Hepton Road |
| Iglesia De Christo Vino Nuevo |
301 N. Elm Street |
| Living Gospel Church |
302 W. Walnut Street |
| Maranatha Fellowship |
9636 W. Hepton Road |
| Mt. Tabor Church of God |
8424 N. 800 W. |
| Nappanee Brethren in Christ |
1601 N. Main Street |
| Nappanee Church of the Brethren |
301 Mack Drive |
| Nappanee Church of God |
158 E. Centennial Street |
| Nappanee First Brethren Church |
1600 N. Main Street |
| Nappanee First Church of God |
72036 CR 7 |
| Nappanee Missionary Church |
70417 SR 19 |
| New Beginnings Assembly of God |
901 S. Main Street |
| New Life Church |
2673 E. Market Street |
| North Main Street Mennonite |
504 N. Main Street |
| NorthWood Chapel |
28220 CR 52 |
| Union Center Church of the Brethren |
70535 CR 11 |
| Union Grove |
69954 CR 11 |
| United Methodist Church |
301 E. Market Street |
